What Physician Leaders Can Learn From Counseling Psychology

Robert Hicks, PhD


Brian A. Hicks, PhD, LPC


July 10, 2026


Physician Leadership Journal


Volume 13, Issue 4, Pages 45-48


https://doi.org/10.55834/plj.7550754083


Abstract

Physician leaders operate in demanding, high-stakes environments where clinical responsibility, time pressure, and organizational complexity intersect. Adverse patient outcomes, administrative burdens, and evolving systems of care create conditions that require sustained performance under pressure. Leadership adds another layer: supporting colleagues who are navigating the same conditions. Increasingly, physician leaders are expected to coach others through difficult experiences, adding to their emotional burden. Physician leaders can learn from counseling psychology to become effective coaches.




Over decades of research, counseling psychology has examined how individuals in positions of authority — most notably counselors — effectively help others navigate complex personal and professional challenges. Physician leaders occupy a parallel role. They, too, hold influence and are tasked with supporting the growth, performance, and well-being of others.

One of the most consistent findings from counseling research is that the single most important skill in these helping relationships, particularly in demanding, high-pressure environments, is the ability to regulate one’s own emotional state.(1)

WHY EMOTIONAL REGULATION MATTERS

Leaders function much like the sun within their sphere of influence, exerting a powerful gravitational pull that shapes the movement, alignment, and stability of everything around them. Their presence — through attitudes, decisions, and emotional tone — creates a kind of psychological gravity that others naturally orient toward, whether consciously or not.

Just as planets settle into predictable orbits around the sun’s mass and consistency, team members calibrate their behavior and emotional responses to the leader’s steadiness or volatility. When a leader is grounded, regulated, and intentional, the system stabilizes; when they are erratic or reactive, the system experiences disruption and destabilization. In this sense, leadership is less about direct control and more about the invisible but constant force of influence that organizes the entire environment.

THE REALITY OF EMOTIONAL CONTAGION

One of the most important findings from counseling and organizational research is that emotional states are contagious. Individuals unconsciously “catch” and synchronize with the emotional states of others through verbal and nonverbal cues — such as tone of voice, facial expression, posture, and pacing — resulting in a shared or aligned emotional experience. This process is known as emotional contagion.(2)

In practical terms, it means that a leader’s emotional state can influence the emotional climate of a conversation, team, or organization without explicit intention. For physician leaders, this implies that their level of calm, urgency, frustration, or steadiness is not contained within them; it is transmitted to others and shapes how those around them think, feel, and respond. A leader’s regulated presence can interrupt cycles of anxiety, frustration, or hopelessness.

Emotional reactivity, on the other hand, does just the opposite. For physician leaders and coaches, emotional regulation is not optional because a leader’s internal state is not neutral; it is structural. It is the mechanism that establishes the emotional climate under which effective work can be accomplished.

TEN PRACTICAL STRATEGIES FOR EMOTIONAL REGULATION

Emotional regulation, in practice, is a set of behavioral guidelines enacted in real time through observable conduct: how a person enters conversations, attends to others, responds under pressure, and navigates emotionally charged exchanges.(3)

Emotional regulation is not a discrete technique, but the continuous management of cognitive and behavioral responses so that emotional contagion works in your favor and yields the benefits of clear thinking, constructive communication, and relational integrity.

The following guidelines translate counseling principles for regulating emotion into actionable behaviors.

1. Notice Early, Not Late

Emotional regulation begins with awareness. Most dysregulation occurs because leaders recognize their emotional state after it has already influenced their behavior. Develop the habit of early detection:

  • Notice physiological cues (chest tightness, increased heart rate, shallow breathing).

  • Pay attention to cognitive signals (urgency, irritation, defensiveness).

  • Recognize behavioral impulses (interrupting, fixing, withdrawing).

The earlier you notice, the easier it is to regulate.

2. Pause Before Responding

A brief pause is one of the most effective regulatory tools available. Before responding in a challenging moment:

  • Take one or two slow breaths.

  • Delay your verbal response by a few seconds.

  • Allow the initial emotional surge to settle.

  • Ask a question to slow down your reaction.

This pause creates a gap between stimulus and response, allowing you to act intentionally rather than react impulsively.

3. Stay Curious Instead of Certain

Resist the urge to reach a conclusion too quickly; explore the situation before interpreting or acting. Emotional reactivity often pushes leaders to draw premature conclusions.

A regulated stance replaces certainty with curiosity. Curiosity is not passive or vague. It is an active stance characterized by:

  • Asking before telling.

  • Exploring before concluding.

  • Understanding before evaluating.

A simple operational rule is: Before making a statement, ask yourself, “Have I asked enough questions to understand this?” If not, ask one more.

4. Regulate Your Urge to Fix

The urge to fix is also called “righting reflex.”(4) It is an internal pull to say or think, “Here’s what you should do,” or “Let me just tell them.” It is triggered by emotional states such as anxiety, impatience, responsibility pressure, and discomfort with ambiguity. When these emotions are unregulated, they create pressure to fix or make things “right” as you see it.

When you feel the urge to fix:

  • Acknowledge it internally (“I want to solve this right now.”).

  • Delay action and ask a question instead.

  • Allow the other person to think before you intervene.

Regulating the urge to fix does not mean eliminating it; it means not acting on it immediately. Fixing is often an emotional response disguised as problem-solving.

5. Maintain a Regulated Physical Presence

Before people process your words, they process your presence. Use your body, voice, and pacing to convey steadiness, composure, and attentiveness — especially in emotionally charged situations. A regulated presence includes:

  • Steady tone of voice.

  • Slower speech cadence.

  • Relaxed posture.

  • Neutral to receptive facial expressions.

  • Allowing pauses in conversation.

Let your body and voice communicate stability, not urgency. These signals transmit a state of calm that can spread to others.

6. Separate Your Emotions from Theirs

Leaders often absorb others’ emotional tone, especially in demanding environments. For example, in high-stress conversations, emotions tend to transfer quickly. In these moments, remind yourself: “I can understand this without becoming it.”

Leaders who consistently separate their emotions from others:

  • Are perceived as calm and steady.

  • Reduce emotional escalation in teams.

  • Handle difficult conversations more effectively.

  • Avoid emotional exhaustion.

Separating your emotion from theirs means staying connected without becoming emotionally entangled. This prevents emotional fatigue and preserves clarity.

7. Reframe Before You React

Pause long enough to reinterpret what is happening before deciding how to respond. Instead of taking your first interpretation as fact, deliberately consider alternative explanations that are potentially more accurate, balanced, or useful. Instead of reacting, ask yourself:

  • What else could be true here?

  • What am I not seeing yet?

  • What would a neutral observer notice?

  • What factors might be influencing this?

In a nutshell, reframing means asking yourself, “What is the most useful way to understand this now?” Reframing expands perspective and reduces emotional intensity.

8. Build Regulation Into Routine Behavior

Emotional regulation is strengthened through repetition, not occasional effort. Building regulation into routine behavior means embedding small, repeatable emotional regulation actions into your everyday work so that steadiness becomes automatic — not something you only try during difficult moments.

Integrate small practices into daily work:

  • Before every conversation, make regulation your default entry point.

  • Before responding, insert a consistent delay.

  • When you feel the urge to “fix,” inquire instead.

  • After challenging, emotionally exhausting interactions, reset deliberately.

These micro-practices accumulate into consistent regulatory capacity. In other words, don’t rely on willpower under pressure; make emotional regulation your default operating system, not your emergency response.

9. Accept That Regulation Is Imperfect

Everyone becomes dysregulated at times. Accepting that regulation is imperfect means recognizing that you will not consistently remain calm, measured, or fully in control — and that is okay. Effective leadership depends less on perfection and more on how quickly and skillfully you recover when you are not.

The core skills are:

  • Notice quickly. Recognize when you have reacted impulsively.

  • Reset quickly rather than escalating.

  • Reflect on what happened and learn from it.

  • Acknowledge missteps when appropriate.

Emotional regulation is not about never reacting; it is about how quickly and skillfully you recover.

10. Remember: Your State Becomes the Environment

Understanding and constantly reminding yourself that your state becomes the environment is one of the most powerful — and often under-recognized — forms of influence. If your internal state is:

  • Rushed, the environment feels rushed.

  • Tense, the environment feels tense.

  • Calm, the environment feels steady.

  • Curious, the environment feels open.

A simple real-time question is: “What kind of emotional environment am I creating now?”

SUMMARY

Physician leaders carry more than responsibility; they carry influence. Their emotional state does not stay contained; it spreads. Through everyday interactions, leaders set the tone for how others think, feel, and perform. Emotional steadiness creates stability. Reactivity creates disruption. In this way, leadership is less about control and more about the emotional conditions a leader consistently creates.

Emotional regulation is not optional; it is mandatory. It is not an abstract concept; it is a daily practice expressed through behavior. It shows up in the demeanor of leaders and how they pause, listen, respond, and guide others through difficult moments. The above guidelines are not meant to be used occasionally, but to become part of a leader’s default operating style. Perfection is not the goal; awareness, adjustment, and recovery are.

References

  1. Prikhidko A, Swank JM. Emotion regulation for counselors. J Couns Dev. 2018;96:206–212. https://doi.org/10.1002/jcad.12193 .

  2. Barsade SG. The ripple effect: Emotional contagion and its influence on group behavior. Adm Sci Q. 2002;47(4):644–675. https://doi.org/10.2307/3094912 .

  3. Gross JJ. Emotion regulation: current status and future prospects. Psychol Inq. 2015;26(1):1–26. https://doi.org/10.1080/1047840X.2014.940781 .

  4. Hicks RF. The Process of Highly Effective Coaching: An Evidence-Based Framework, 2nd ed. New York: Routledge; 2024.

Robert Hicks, PhD
Robert Hicks, PhD

Robert F. Hicks, PhD, is a clinical professor of organizational behavior at the University of Texas at Dallas and the founding director of the Organizational Behavior, Coaching, and Consulting Program. A licensed psychologist, he is the author of The Process of Highly Effective Coaching and focuses on leadership and executive coaching.


Brian A. Hicks, PhD, LPC
Brian A. Hicks, PhD, LPC

Brian A. Hicks, PhD, LPC, is an assistant professor of professional counseling at Stephen F. Austin State University. A licensed professional counselor, he teaches counselor development, ethics, and clinical supervision and brings experience in academic leadership, professional development, and mentorship in both online and traditional higher education settings.

Interested in sharing leadership insights? Contribute


LEADERSHIP IS LEARNED™

For over 50 years.

The American Association for Physician Leadership has helped physicians develop their leadership skills through education, career development, thought leadership and community building.

The American Association for Physician Leadership (AAPL) changed its name from the American College of Physician Executives (ACPE) in 2014. We may have changed our name, but we are the same organization that has been serving physician leaders since 1975.

CONTACT US

Mail Processing Address
PO Box 96503 I BMB 97493
Washington, DC 20090-6503

Payment Remittance Address
PO Box 745725
Atlanta, GA 30374-5725
(800) 562-8088
(813) 287-8993 Fax
customerservice@physicianleaders.org

CONNECT WITH US

LOOKING TO ENGAGE YOUR STAFF?

AAPL provides leadership development programs designed to retain valuable team members and improve patient outcomes.

©2026 American Association for Physician Leadership, Inc. All rights reserved.